On July 1, 2021, I will complete my 8th year at UUFSCC. That makes me the longest serving minister of the 10 ministers who have served this Fellowship since 1983.
Some surveys put the average protestant pastor’s tenure at between 3 and 4 years. This seems about right for UUism as well. There’s even a term in congregational ministry called “the dangerous third year” because that is often the time when “the honeymoon is over” sets in and ministers and congregations wrestle with behaviors which seemed quaint and charming at first but have now become irritating and frustrating. It is a dangerous time for any potential long-term relationship—when emotions dominate decision making.
For me, 3 to 4 years is not a long-term relationship. It’s a phase. Congregations are a complex culture and it can take a decade or more to understand, so a 4-year tenure seems risky. Parting of ways after a few years can negatively impact the congregational culture and will challenge any future minister.
Of course, not every pairing of minister/congregation is worth saving. Some pairings are just bad. But can a good “fit” for the long haul be determined after the first conflict? After only 3 years? When are differences truly irreconcilable? This is likely why US divorce rate is 50%. But is our divorce rate and our tendency to change ministers after 4 years because of poor fit or misunderstood expectations?
I know a minister who was asked to leave after one year of service. The minister and congregation went through some gut-wrenching discussions and both decided to try for another year. They are still together after 15 years.
I’ve read that a pastor’s ministry only “really” begins after 10 years. I never understood what that meant until now. There’s a depth of respecting 100+ personal life stories that only comes from regular meetings and conversations. There’s a depth of connection that only comes with time. There’s depth of trust that only becomes solidified with time. There are benefits of long-term ministry that go beyond continuity. Seeing children grow, seeing people age, sitting with congregants in hospitals, and being with members as they die does not create continuity—these create deep relationships.
At this phase of my ministry, I see the benefit to our congregation, to me, and for our denomination with tenures that are long-term. As I look forward to my sabbatical in the autumn, I also look forward to returning to UUFSCC to resume our long-term journey together……………………yours in shared ministry………………..Russ
